What must a UK employer do before hiring someone?
Check the candidate’s right to work before employment starts, keep the evidence, and run a selection process that can be shown to be consistent. The Equality Act regulates the arrangements you make for deciding who to offer a job, not just the offer itself, and separate rules restrict health questions before an offer is made.
Most employment guidance, including our own UK employment law guide, starts at the contract. Contracts, wages, working time, dismissal and redundancy are all well covered. The stage before the contract gets far less attention, and it carries two of the largest single penalties a small employer can incur.
This guide covers the legal frame around choosing a person: right to work, discrimination in the selection arrangements, what you may and may not ask, how selection tests fit, and what you must do with candidate data afterwards. It is about process, not about what makes a good hire.
Right to work: the largest avoidable penalty
Government guidance is unambiguous about timing:
You must check that a job applicant is allowed to work for you in the UK before you employ them.
There are three acceptable routes: an online check using a share code, a manual check of original documents, or an identity service provider using digital identity verification technology. British and Irish citizens cannot obtain an online share code, so their checks go through the other routes.
The penalties for getting this wrong are the reason it belongs at the top of any hiring process. The Home Office code of practice in force from 1 October 2026 sets the civil penalty as a starting point of 45,000 GBP per worker for a first breach within the last three years, rising to 60,000 GBP per worker for a repeat breach.
Where an employer knew or had “reasonable cause to believe” the person lacked the right to work, the offence is criminal and carries up to five years’ imprisonment and an unlimited fine.
The protection against the civil penalty is the check itself. Government guidance puts it plainly:
You will not have to pay the civil penalty if you can show you made the correct right to work checks.
That is the statutory excuse, and it only exists if you can produce evidence. Copies must be kept during the employment and for two years after it ends, with the date of each check recorded. Where someone’s right to work is time limited, a follow-up check is required.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| When | Before employment starts |
| How | Online share code, original documents, or an IDVT provider |
| Keep | Copies, during employment and 2 years after |
| Record | The date the check was made |
| Repeat | Follow-up check where the right to work is time limited |
| First breach | 45,000 GBP per worker |
| Repeat breach | 60,000 GBP per worker |
Discrimination applies to the arrangements, not just the decision
Section 39(1) of the Equality Act 2010 is worth reading in full, because its first limb is the one small employers overlook:
An employer (A) must not discriminate against a person (B) in the arrangements A makes for deciding to whom to offer employment; as to the terms on which A offers B employment; by not offering B employment.
“The arrangements A makes for deciding to whom to offer employment” covers the advert, the shortlisting criteria, the interview structure and any test you set. A process can therefore be unlawful even where the eventual hiring decision was defensible, because the arrangements themselves disadvantaged someone.
The nine protected characteristics under section 4 are age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation.
Section 39(5) adds that the duty to make reasonable adjustments applies to an employer, and ACAS confirms this bites throughout: the duty “can be relevant at any stage of the recruitment process”.
You cannot ask about health before an offer
Section 60 of the Equality Act restricts pre-offer health questions:
A person (A) to whom an application for work is made must not ask about the health of the applicant (B) before offering work to B, or where A is not in a position to offer work to B, before including B in a pool of applicants
ACAS states the practical rule: you must not ask a job applicant about their health or any disability at any stage of the application or interview process unless an exception applies.
The exceptions matter, and two of them exist precisely to let you run a fair assessment:
- Establishing whether the applicant can comply with a requirement to undergo an assessment, or whether a duty to make reasonable adjustments arises in relation to that assessment
- Establishing whether the applicant can carry out a function that is intrinsic to the work
- Monitoring diversity of applicants
- Positive action under section 158
- An occupational requirement to have a particular disability
Two points of structure are easy to misread. First, section 60 is enforceable only by the Equality and Human Rights Commission, so asking the question is not itself something a candidate can bring a claim over. Second, section 60(3) to (5) makes clear that while asking does not by itself contravene the disability provisions, acting on the answer can.
The question is low risk; the decision made in reliance on it is not.
Where selection tests fit
Section 60(12) defines an assessment broadly:
An assessment is an interview or other process designed to give an indication of a person’s suitability for the work concerned
So a written exercise, a work sample or an aptitude test is an assessment in the same sense an interview is, and the same obligations attach.
Be honest about what official guidance does and does not say. There is no government or ACAS guidance that validates particular test types, endorses providers, or tells you that a given test predicts job performance. We looked for it specifically and did not find it. What the official sources do set out is how any selection method must be run.
Consistency. ACAS advises selecting the applicants who best match the job description and person specification, doing so fairly for each person, and using “a consistent decision-making process, such as a scoring system”, ideally with two or more people involved.
Transparency. ACAS adds that you should use the information you told applicants you would use to make decisions. The Information Commissioner’s Office, which names “psychometric tests, skills tests, or aptitude tests” among shortlisting methods, says you should inform candidates about the selection criteria before you collect the information.
Job relevance. Government guidance on recruiting disabled people warns that a person specification “must not exclude disabled people from applying for a job”, while accepting that some jobs have an essential requirement that cannot be met with a reasonable adjustment.
A test that screens on something the job does not actually require is the clearest way to create an unlawful arrangement under section 39(1)(a).
Adjustments. You can ask whether someone needs help to take part in a selection test or interview, and adjustments must be made where reasonable. Government guidance gives the example of allowing candidates to complete a written test using a computer.
Data. The ICO advises pseudonymising candidate information where possible when using tests or assessments, and says you must not collect excessive information at interview.
The practical reading is that a test is lawful as an input to a decision when it is relevant to the job, administered the same way for everyone, adjusted where a candidate needs it, explained in advance, and not the sole basis for rejecting someone who could do the work with an adjustment.
If you want to understand what a given assessment format actually measures before deciding whether it belongs in your process, this explainer on situational judgement assessments sets out the format from the candidate’s side.
Criminal records
Spent convictions are generally off limits. Government guidance states that applicants do not have to tell you about convictions that are spent, that you must treat the applicant as if the conviction had not happened, and that you cannot refuse to employ the person because of it. Some roles, schools among them, are exempt.
Where a check is appropriate, the DBS framework has four levels:
| Check | Shows |
|---|---|
| Basic | Unspent convictions and conditional cautions |
| Standard | Spent and unspent convictions and cautions |
| Enhanced | Standard, plus relevant local police information |
| Enhanced with barred lists | Enhanced, plus whether the applicant is barred from the role |
If you carry out criminal record checks you must have a policy on employing ex-offenders and show it to any applicant who asks. A DBS check has no official expiry date. Scotland and Northern Ireland run separate processes.
Candidate data after the decision
Recruitment generates personal data about people you did not hire, and the obligation does not end with the rejection email. The ICO’s position is that you must not keep information longer than you need it, that data protection law sets no specific timescale for recruitment records, and that you should therefore set clear retention periods yourself.
Its working guide is not to keep information beyond the statutory period in which a legal claim could be brought, referencing the Limitation Act 1980 for England and Wales, the Limitation (Northern Ireland) Order 1989, and the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973. Holding unsuccessful candidates on a waiting list requires having told them so beforehand.
One caveat on this section: the ICO’s recruitment guidance is published in draft, its consultation has closed, and it is under review in light of the Data (Use and Access) Act. Treat it as the regulator’s current thinking rather than a settled final position, and check the ICO site before relying on it for a retention policy.
A defensible process, in order
- Write the person specification first, and keep it to what the job requires
- Decide the selection criteria and tell applicants what you will use
- Offer adjustments at the point of application, and again before any test or interview
- Score consistently, ideally with more than one assessor
- Keep health questions out until an offer is made, unless an exception applies
- Check right to work before employment starts, copy the evidence, record the date
- Set a retention period for candidate data and apply it
ACAS summarises the legal position on process in one line: there are no set processes required by law, but employers must follow a fair process. The absence of a prescribed procedure is exactly why writing your own down matters. A consistent process you can evidence is the defence.
Common mistakes
Checking right to work after the start date. The statutory excuse depends on the check being made before employment begins.
Treating the advert as outside the rules. Section 39(1)(a) covers the arrangements, which includes how the role was advertised and shortlisted.
Asking about health to be helpful. Even where the intent is accommodation, the pre-offer restriction applies unless one of the section 60 exceptions covers it.
Using a test because it is standard in the sector. Relevance to the specific job is what makes it defensible, and no official guidance validates any test by name.
Keeping unsuccessful applications indefinitely. Set a retention period and apply it.
Conclusion
Hiring is the point where a company stops being an administrative structure and starts carrying obligations towards another person. Two of those obligations are expensive to get wrong: a right to work check that was never made, and a selection process that cannot be shown to be consistent.
Neither requires a large HR function. The right to work check is a documented step before day one. The rest is a written person specification, criteria shared in advance, adjustments offered, and scores recorded. That is a morning’s work, and it is also the evidence if the decision is ever questioned.
Related Corpy resources
Can a UK employer ask a job applicant about their health?
Not before offering work, under section 60 of the Equality Act 2010. Exceptions include establishing whether the applicant needs a reasonable adjustment for an assessment, whether they can carry out a function intrinsic to the work, diversity monitoring, positive action, and an occupational requirement to have a particular disability.
Asking is enforceable only by the EHRC, but acting on the answer can breach the disability provisions.
What is the penalty for employing someone without the right to work?
The Home Office code of practice in force from 1 October 2026 sets a starting point of 45,000 GBP per worker for a first breach within three years and 60,000 GBP per worker for a repeat breach. Where the employer knew or had reasonable cause to believe the person lacked permission, the offence is criminal, carrying up to five years’ imprisonment and an unlimited fine.
Are aptitude or psychometric tests legal in UK recruitment?
There is no official UK guidance validating or prohibiting particular tests. A test is an assessment under section 60(12) of the Equality Act, so the general rules apply: it must relate to the job, be run consistently, be explained to candidates in advance, and be adjusted where a disabled candidate needs it.
Discrimination law covers the arrangements for deciding who to offer a job, which includes any test you set.
